When parents are against a relationship

December 20, 2018 at 5:44 PM
Yaakov asked 5 years ago
Dear Rabbi Alon Anava, First of all thank you for the tremendous work you do for the Am Israel. I would like to get an advice from you. Some 6 years ago I met a wonderful girl BH, and we have been in a close relationship with her since. During this time we got to know each other very well, and we would like to create a proper Jewish family. Problem is that we are from different countries, and in my family it is unacceptable for a family member to marry someone from another culture, and this is something they take very seriously for already many generations. I understand and respect this completely, but on the other hand this definately is not a decisive factor. I love my family, and would never want to hurt their feelings, everything they do is to ensure happy and good life for me. On the other hand, I know that this girl is someone I would like to devote my future life to, we have developed strong love and respect for each other. At the moment I am stuck, cannot take action into any direction, but this brings lots of emotional distress to everyone involved, so I have to do something. I know halachically it is allowed to go against the will of parents in this situation, but my problem is at some deeper emotional level. I would be happy if You could find time to give me an advice on this. May H-m bless You and Your family with all the brachot, and continue to do your work in good health and simcha. Shabat Shalom. Yaakov
2 Answers
Rabbi Yosef Karpman answered 5 years ago
Shalom    1-  Always ask what is the path towards revealing maximal spiritual light? That is the key with finding answers in a scenario such as this.  While keeping your fiancé and yourself happy is obvious, it doesn’t mean that your parents can’t be respected as well. The key is to allow them to realize that your language,cultural traditions. Etc..., would be maintained by your children and that true love is not to be denied.  If parents are lukewarm towards this at first they can still come around later on.   Best Wishes    R.Yosef Karpman 
Rabbi Yosef Karpman answered 5 years ago
Shalom    1-  Always ask what is the path towards revealing maximal spiritual light? That is the key with finding answers in a scenario such as this.  While keeping your fiancé and yourself happy is obvious, it doesn’t mean that your parents can’t be respected as well. The key is to allow them to realize that your language,cultural traditions. Etc..., would be maintained by your children and that true love is not to be denied.  If parents are lukewarm towards this at first they can still come around later on.   Best Wishes    R.Yosef Karpman